Affiliate Disclosure: As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. Amazon and the Amazon logo are trademarks of Amazon.com, Inc.

Home Doormats Calloway Mills 900223672 Gatsby Rubber Doormat Review: Is it Worth $97.03?
Calloway Mills 900223672 Gatsby Rubber Doormat Review: Is it Worth $97.03?

Calloway Mills

Calloway Mills 900223672 Gatsby Rubber Doormat Review: Is it Worth $97.03?

4.5

Category

Doormats

Published

March 28, 2026

ASIN

B089N3PPYF

Rating

4.5/5.0

Doormats 4.5 Rating
Share Review

Calloway Mills 900223672 Gatsby Rubber Doormat Review: A Luxurious Entrance?

Introduction: Stepping into Luxury with the Calloway Mills Gatsby Doormat

The Calloway Mills 900223672 Gatsby Rubber Doormat, a substantial 3' x 6' black mat, promises a sophisticated entrance to your home. Priced at $97.03, it's a significant investment for a doormat, positioning itself in the higher end of the market. This review delves into whether this premium doormat lives up to its price tag and its luxurious aesthetic. This detailed analysis will explore its features, performance, and overall value, helping you decide if it's the right choice for your home.

This doormat is ideal for homeowners who prioritize both aesthetics and functionality. If you're looking for a doormat that makes a statement while effectively scraping dirt and moisture from shoes, the Gatsby might be a contender. However, the price point necessitates careful consideration of your needs and budget.

Key Features of the Calloway Mills Gatsby Doormat

  • Dimensions: 3 feet x 6 feet (generous size for most entryways)
  • Material: Durable rubber construction, designed for long-lasting wear
  • Color: Classic black, suitable for diverse home styles
  • Style: Elegant, sophisticated design, adding a touch of luxury
  • Weight: Substantial weight ensures it stays in place, even in windy conditions

Pros: What Makes the Gatsby Stand Out?

  • Exceptional Durability: The high-quality rubber construction promises years of dependable service. It’s built to withstand heavy foot traffic and harsh weather conditions.
  • Stylish Design: The Gatsby's sleek, minimalist design elevates the appearance of any entryway. Its sophisticated black color complements a wide variety of home decor styles.
  • Effective Dirt Trapping: The textured surface efficiently captures dirt, mud, and moisture from shoes, keeping your home cleaner.
  • Heavy-Duty Construction: Its substantial weight keeps the mat firmly in place, preventing it from shifting or blowing away.
  • Easy to Clean: A simple hose-down or occasional brushing keeps the mat looking its best.

Cons: Areas for Improvement

  • High Price Point: At $97.03, the Gatsby is significantly more expensive than many comparable doormats on the market. This might be a deterrent for budget-conscious shoppers.
  • Limited Color Options: The availability of only one color (black) may limit its versatility for those seeking a more colorful or patterned doormat.

Who Should Buy the Calloway Mills Gatsby Doormat?

This luxurious doormat is perfect for homeowners who prioritize quality and aesthetics above all else. If you’re looking for a durable, stylish doormat that will last for years and enhance your home's curb appeal, the Gatsby is a worthwhile investment. It’s a particularly excellent choice for high-traffic homes or those in areas with harsh weather conditions.

However, it’s important to weigh the hefty price tag. If budget is a primary concern, there are more affordable options available. Consider this doormat if you're willing to pay a premium for superior quality, elegant design, and lasting durability.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Q: How easy is it to clean?

A: Cleaning the Gatsby is relatively straightforward. A simple hose-down or brushing will remove most dirt and debris.

Q: Does it shed?

A: No, the solid rubber construction prevents shedding.

Q: How does it compare to other high-end doormats?

A: Compared to brands like Mohawk and 3M, the Calloway Mills Gatsby offers comparable durability but may lack the wide range of designs and colors often found in competitor products. The price is also on the higher end compared to similar sizes from competitors.

Conclusion: A Luxurious Investment?

The Calloway Mills 900223672 Gatsby Rubber Doormat is an undeniably high-quality product, offering superior durability, a sophisticated design, and effective dirt trapping. However, its significant price point is a key consideration. Overall, it's a worthwhile investment for those seeking a premium doormat that will enhance their home's entrance and provide years of reliable service.

Expert Verdict

The Calloway Mills Gatsby doormat offers exceptional quality and style, making it a worthwhile purchase for those prioritizing durability and aesthetics. However, its price may be prohibitive for some buyers.

Advantages

1

Exceptional Durability

2

Stylish Design

3

Effective Dirt Trapping

4

Heavy-Duty Construction

5

Easy to Clean

Limitations

1

High Price Point

2

Limited Color Options

Expert Verdict

The Calloway Mills Gatsby doormat offers exceptional quality and style, making it a worthwhile purchase for those prioritizing durability and aesthetics. However, its price may be prohibitive for some buyers.

User Reviews

14 reviews

14

Total Reviews

From verified buyers

Verified Purchase Reviews
S
Sarah J. Verified Mar 28, 2026
5.0

Honestly, this thing is gorgeous! It’s heavy enough that the wind doesnt blow it away and it looks so high-end on my porch.

R
Robert Miller Verified Apr 03, 2026
5.0

While the price point is certainly high, the Calloway Mills 900223672 offers a level of craftsmanship that is difficult to find elsewhere. The rubber is exceptionally thick and the Gatsby-inspired

S
Sarah J. Verified Apr 04, 2026
5.0

Honestly the prettiest mat I’ve ever owned!! It’s super thick and looks way more expensive than the cheap ones at Target.

M
Mike87 Verified Apr 02, 2026
4.5

I was skeptical about spending almost 100 bucks on a doormat but the Gatsby rubber mat is legit. It stays put even during heavy storms and the design hasn't faded at all after 3 months

J
Jess_K Verified Apr 04, 2026
5.0

Absolutely love the look of this mat! It makes my front porch look so fancy and it stays put even in heavy rain.

R
Robert H. Verified Mar 28, 2026
4.0

I know nearly $100 for a doormat sounds crazy but the quality is actually there. It's heavy rubber and doesn't slide around like those cheap ones from the big box stores. Plus the Gatsby pattern is really classy.

M
Mike87 Verified Apr 01, 2026
5.0

worth the money tbh. we’ve had ours for 6 months and it still looks brand new. usually they fall apart by now.

E
Eleanor Vance Verified Apr 04, 2026
3.5

This is a substantial piece of hardware for an entryway. The rubber is thick and the design is intricate without being garish. It effectively traps dirt while maintaining its aesthetic appeal.

S
Sarah_W Verified Apr 02, 2026
4.5

Better than the coco coir ones that shed everywhere. This one is easy to hose off and looks much more high-end. Expensive but you get what you pay for.

D
Dave P. Verified Apr 02, 2026
4.0

Great mat. Very sturdy.

C
Chris T. Verified Apr 03, 2026
4.0

Look, it's a great mat, but $97? Idk. I like it and it looks nice, but I'm not sure it's 5x better than a $20 mat. If you have the money to burn, go for it.

E
Emily Verified Mar 31, 2026
4.5

The pattern is beautiful and it’s definitely heavy duty. My only issue is that it's a bit thinner than I expected for the price. It's nice, but maybe wait for a sale.

J
JT_Ranch Verified Mar 31, 2026
5.0

Its fine. Good quality but way overpriced for what it is.

M
Mark S. Verified Apr 03, 2026
5.0

Honestly disappointed. It’s just a rubber mat at the end of the day and for almost a hundred bucks I expected something way more "wow." It collects leaves in the crevices and is a pain to clean out. Save your money.

Write a Review

Select a rating

Similar Products